Outcomes of Onlay versus Sublay Mesh Hernioplasty in Primary Ventral Wall Hernia Repair: A Prospective Randomized Comparison

Authors

  • Syeda Sabah Zehra
  • Shabbar Hussain Changazi g
  • Hina Sulaiman
  • Iqtidar Hussain
  • Ailezaz Hussain Shah
  • Masoor Ali Khan

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.37018/GSQB5079

Keywords:

Hernia, Ventral, Herniorrhaphy, Surgical mesh, Seroma, Pain, Postoperative

Abstract

Background: Mesh repair is standard for ventral hernias over 2 cm, but the optimal mesh plane remains debated, and evidence from low-resource regions is scarce. This study compared onlay and sublay mesh hernioplasty for primary ventral wall hernia.
Methodology: This single-center, open-label randomized controlled trial (IRB Ref. No. IRB/05/2024/PHQG; ClinicalTrials.gov NCT07896278) was conducted at PHQ Teaching Hospital, Gilgit (August 2025 to October 2026). After written informed consent, 76 consecutively sampled adults aged 20–70 years with a primary ventral hernia (defect 3–10 cm) were randomized to onlay or sublay repair (38 each) and followed for six months. Primary outcome was any wound complication; secondary outcomes were operative duration, visual analogue scale (VAS) pain, return to normal activity and recurrence, recorded on a structured proforma. SPSS 26.0 was used for Mann–Whitney U and Fisher's exact tests with 95% confidence intervals (CI); p < 0.05 was significant.
Results: Mean age was 38.2 ± 8.1 years; 72.4% were women; onlay patients were older (median 40 vs. 33.5 years; p = 0.021); groups were otherwise comparable. Wound complications occurred in 18.4% (onlay) vs. 2.6% (sublay) of patients (odds ratio 8.35, 95% CI 0.97–71.6; p = 0.056). Sublay repair took longer (mean difference 8.4 minutes, 95% CI 6.1–10.7) but had lower median VAS scores at 12 hours (5 vs. 6), discharge (2 vs. 4) and two weeks (1 vs. 2), and earlier return to normal activity (median 12.5 vs. 14 days) (all p ≤ 0.001). All three recurrences followed onlay repair (p = 0.24). Adjustment for age and body mass index did not alter estimates.
Conclusion: Sublay hernioplasty prolonged operative duration by a mean of 8.4 minutes but was associated with less postoperative pain and earlier return to normal activity. Its lower wound complication and recurrence rates were not significant; larger multicenter trials are required.

References

1. Henriksen NA, Montgomery A, Kaufmann R, Berrevoet F, East B, Fischer J, et al. Guidelines for treatment of umbilical and epigastric hernias from the European Hernia Society and Americas Hernia Society. Br J Surg. 2020;107(3):171-90. doi:10.1002/bjs.11489

2. Muysoms FE, Miserez M, Berrevoet F, Campanelli G, Champault GG, Chelala E, et al. Classification of primary and incisional abdominal wall hernias. Hernia. 2009;13(4):407-14. doi:10.1007/s10029-009-0518-x

3. Hodgman EI, Watson MJ. Revisiting the anterior rectus sheath repair for incisional hernia: a 10-year experience. World J Surg. 2017;41(3):713-21. doi:10.1007/s00268-016-3774-9

4. Rives J, Pire JC, Flament JB, Palot JP, Body C. Le traitement des grandes éventrations. Nouvelles indications thérapeutiques à propos de 322 cas. Chirurgie. 1985;111(3):215-25. [In French]

5. Stoppa RE. The treatment of complicated groin and incisional hernias. World J Surg. 1989;13(5):545-54.

6. Saleem S, Naqvi SRQ, Luqman A, Razzaque H, Khan MH, Haq QTU. Outcomes of onlay versus sublay mesh hernioplasty for ventral abdominal hernias. Pak Armed Forces Med J. 2024;74(6):1524-7. doi:10.51253/pafmj.v74i6.8732

7. Basavarajappa M, Anilkumar T, Reddy V. Comparative analysis of onlay versus sublay mesh repair for ventral hernia: a prospective randomized study. Int J Med Pharm Res. 2025;6(2):76-86. doi:10.5281/zenodo.15161668

8. Babar Y, Shah M, Ullah R. Comparison of efficacy and safety in sublay versus onlay mesh repair for para-umbilical hernia: a randomized controlled trial. J Health Rehabil Res. 2024;4(1):19-22. doi:10.61919/jhrr.v4i1.320

9. Ahmad QA, Changazi SH, Hussain A, Sarwar MZ, Afzal MN, Fatimah N, et al. Onlay versus sublay mesh hernioplasty for paraumbilical hernia repair. J Fatima Jinnah Med Univ. 2019;13(1):3-6.

10. Beckers Perletti L, Spoelders F, Berrevoet F. Association between surgical hernia repair techniques and the incidence of seroma: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Hernia. 2022;26(1):3-15. doi:10.1007/s10029-021-02531-4

11. Venclauskas L, Maleckas A, Kiudelis M. One-year follow-up after incisional hernia treatment: results of a prospective randomized study. Hernia. 2010;14(6):575-82. doi:10.1007/s10029-010-0686-8

12. Pereira C, Gururaj S. Onlay versus sublay mesh repair for incisional hernias: a systematic review. Cureus. 2023;15(1):e34156. doi:10.7759/cureus.34156

13. Sanders DL, Pawlak MM, Simons MP, Aufenacker T, Balla A, Berger C, et al. Midline incisional hernia guidelines: the European Hernia Society. Br J Surg. 2023;110(12):1732-68. doi:10.1093/bjs/znad284

14. Lwanga SK, Lemeshow S. Sample size determination in health studies: a practical manual. Geneva: World Health Organization; 1991.

15. Zia MK, Younis S, Ashraf A, Afridi SK, Subhan F, Sadiq MA. Compare the efficacy and safety between onlay versus sublay mesh repair for para-umbilical hernia. Pak J Med Health Sci. 2022;16(1):1112-4. doi:10.53350/pjmhs221611112

16. Muysoms F, Campanelli G, Champault GG, DeBeaux AC, Dietz UA, Jeekel J, et al. EuraHS: the development of an international online platform for registration and outcome measurement of ventral abdominal wall hernia repair. Hernia. 2012;16(3):239-50. doi:10.1007/s10029-012-0912-7

17. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Surgical site infection (SSI) event. In: National Healthcare Safety Network (NHSN) Patient Safety Component Manual. Chapter 9. Atlanta (GA): CDC; January 2026.

18. Ullah SE, Hussain MI, Javed I. A randomized controlled comparison of sublay and onlay mesh techniques in ventral abdominal wall hernia repair. Pak J Med Sci. 2026;42(ICON26):S26-S30. doi:10.12669/pjms.42.(ICON26).15688

19. Khan B, Qureshi R, Bai P, Iqbal M. Comparison of post-operative pain and complications between onlay and sublay mesh repair of incisional hernia in tertiary care hospital in Pakistan. J Bahria Univ Med Dent Coll. 2026;16(3):777-83. doi:10.51985/JBUMDC2026977

20. Köckerling F, Koch A, Lorenz R, Schug-Pass C, Stechemesser B, Reinpold W. How long do we need to follow-up our hernia patients to find the real recurrence rate? Front Surg. 2015;2:24. doi:10.3389/fsurg.2015.00024

Downloads

Published

18.11.2026

How to Cite

1.
Zehra SS, Sulaiman H. Outcomes of Onlay versus Sublay Mesh Hernioplasty in Primary Ventral Wall Hernia Repair: A Prospective Randomized Comparison. J Fatima Jinnah Med Univ [Internet]. 2026 Nov. 18 [cited 2026 Nov. 18];20(3):170-6. Available from: https://jfjmu.com/index.php/ojs/article/view/1415

Most read articles by the same author(s)